There's no better way to unwind after 2 hectic weeks of exams than a short and sweet independent, local film in honor of
Water Week. The advanced screening at the
Garneau tonight was a documentary showcasing the negative outcomes of Alberta oilsands development titled
White Water Black Gold (By David Lavallee). As a pro-oil industry resident of Alberta who has worked closely with some of the cast at work and at school, this film hit close to home.
The onslaught of problems presented- from the muderous Syncrude tailings ponds to the issues of water scarcity to the threats of fish and wildlife, and human disease was simply
horrific. Although the fingers of the First Nations were pointed directly at oil giants like
Suncor,
Syncrude,
Enbridge, and government agencies such as
Alberta Environment,
Environment Canada,
Energy Resources Conservation Board, and
National Energy Board, I did not feel this to be the solution.
Yes. Oil sand tailings have killed countless numbers of birds and fish and threatened the habitats of other wildlife.
Yes. The use of tremendous quantities of water to generate the oil has put our water supply in danger.
Yes. Environmental pollution contribute to global warming.
Yes. Environmental chemicals have led to an increase in outbreaks of human disease such as cancer.
What is the underlying problem here? Is it the Oil industry's insatiable thirst for economic gains? Or the simple principle of supply and demand?
Figure 1. The faster than exponential growth rate of the global human population.
This says it all. More people means higher demand for essential resources of survival: food, clothing, shelter- all of which depend on oil. Is this growing global demand for oil triggered by the federal government or the oil and pipelines industries? Or is it self-inflicted?
White Water Balck Gold scares me because we don't have an answer. (And by posing these unanswered questions to HR reps of oil companies will most definitely make them look stupid, as the case for
anyone else) We do not know where the carrying capacity of our planet lies- nor do we know of any alternative efficient, reliable and environmentally friendly methods of obtaining energy. Before we put the easy blame on government and oil companies for the damage, I encourage you to think about whether you are
really ready to return to a primitive way of life.
And do you have a better solution to satiate the global demand for energy than oil?